Blue Cross Blue Shield Medicare Supplement Plans Cost & Coverage (2024)

If you’re in the market for a Medigap plan, Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) might be exactly what you’re looking for. They offer all 10 available Medigap plans and support millions of older adults across the country. Depending on where you live, you may even have access to add-ons like hearing aid coverage or dental insurance. In this review, we’ll get into everything you need to know about BCBS Medigap plans, including plans and benefits, cost, and how to purchase a plan.

Unlike other insurance companies we’ve reviewed, such as Aetna, BCBS isn’t a single company. It’s actually an umbrella term for an association of 34 independently operated BCBS companies. Here’s where it can get confusing: Many of these companies go by a different name.

Some of these names include:

• Highmark Blue Shield
• Capital BlueCross
• Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
• Independence Blue Cross
• Florida Blue

If you decide to give BCBS a serious look, you will need to find the local company that provides coverage to your ZIP code. Below, we’ll explain exactly how to do that. Depending on where you live, you might end up with more than one option to compare.

BCBS, as a whole, provides all 10 Medicare plans. Not every individual BCBS company offers every plan, though. You’ll need to check with your local provider to see which plans are available to you.

Here’s a brief look at the main benefits and what each plan offers.

*Plans C and F are available only to people who became eligible for Medicare coverage before 2020.

Now that you’ve learned a bit about each type of plan, let’s figure out which one is right for you. Our outline below will help you better understand which plan might work best for you or your spouse.

Seniors with limited funds who don’t go to the doctors as often

Do you rarely visit the doctor? Are you active and healthy? Then you may not need as much supplemental coverage as others. Plan N could be a good option for you, given its low premium. Just know that you’ll owe a $20 copay for each office visit and a $50 copay for ER visits.

Seniors with a chronic illness, frequent appointments, or needed surgeries

If you know that you’ll be regularly attending doctor’s appointments, scheduling surgeries, or visiting specialists, a Plan G high-deductible option may be a good fit. In 2024, Plan G has a $2,800 deductible. In other words, after you pay $2,800 in out-of-pocket costs, the plan kicks in to help pay your out-of-pocket Medicare costs.

Seniors who love to travel

International travel is a popular way to spend your retirement years. Any older adult with the travel bug should consider plans C, D, F, G, M, or N. Having 80 percent of qualifying emergency care costs covered will lessen the financial blow if you experience a medical emergency while traveling abroad.

Seniors who want basic coverage and lower premiums

BCBS’ Medigap Plans A and B take care of your copayments and coinsurance from Original Medicare Part A and Part B. This can make the cost of routine appointments, home health care, hospice care, and hospital stays more predictable and affordable. And, with these plans, you’re not paying for coverage you won’t use. Of course, that could mean you’ll face a few unexpected expenses.

All BCBS Medigap plans have associated costs. These can include deductibles, premiums, copays, and coinsurance. Your premium is what you’d owe every month while you hold the policy, so it’s something you’ll want to factor into your monthly budget.

In the table below, we’ve provided example prices for a 65-year-old nonsmoking male with four independent BCBS companies. Your actual premium price for that company would vary based on your ZIP code, age, sex, and tobacco use, so the numbers below should only be used as examples to give you a general idea.

*Estimated premiums for a nonsmoking male born August 1, 1957.

We suggest purchasing your Medigap policy as soon as you’re eligible. That way, you have access to all of the plans and the best prices. When exactly does that eligibility start? Well, there’s a six-month Medigap open enrollment period. It begins on the first day of the month during which you’re 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B.

If that time has already passed for you, don’t worry! You aren’t out of luck. You can still buy a Medigap policy after the enrollment period ends. You just might have limited policy options because the insurance company will use medical underwriting.

Now, let’s walk through how to find your BCBS provider and sign up.

1. Visit the Blue Cross Blue Shield Medigap website to get started. Once there, you need to enter your ZIP code into the search bar on the right side of the screen and then click “Find Coverage.”
   
2. Next, a window will pop up to let you know if Blue Cross Blue Shield provides coverage to your location. If BCBS offers coverage in your area, you will see a list of one or more independent BCBS providers.
   
3. Choose one of the providers listed to start your search for a policy that meets your needs and budget. Clicking on the name will take you to their Medicare Supplement Policy page, where you can learn more.
4. Follow the instructions on the provider’s website to learn about their policy offerings, benefits, and plan costs. Each BCBS company operates its website independently, but from what we saw during our research, the sites are very easy to navigate.If you get stuck, try to locate a customer service number on the insurance provider’s website. Check the top and bottom of the page. For example, the Anthem page lists a number in the top corner of its site.
5. Before you buy, we also recommend calling and comparing costs with other insurance providers. Medigap plans offer the same coverage whether you purchase Plan A from BCBS or another provider like Humana. The biggest difference is the cost and any provider benefits like wellness discounts or access to vision or dental insurance.

BCBS is unique because it’s made up of 34 independent insurance companies. Although that means it may take a few extra steps to find your provider, it also means you get the best of both worlds: the more personalized service of a smaller insurance company with the support and resources of a large one. We also love that many BCBS companies offer add-on benefits for older adults, like coverage for dental care, vision, and hearing exams and services.

Visit our list of the best Medigap plans to learn more about Blue Cross Blue Shield and why they’re a top provider!

Read About Our Panel of Experts

As Editor-in-Chief of the personal finance site MoneyTips.com, Jeff produced hundreds of articles on the subject of retirement, including preventing identity theft, minimizing taxes, investing successfully, preparing for retirement medical costs, protecting your credit score, and making your money last… Learn More About Jeff Hoyt